Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT

Fact Check of the Day

Trump’s False Claims About Coal, the Environment and West Virginia

President Trump claimed that coal was “indestructible,” that West Virginia had one of the strongest state economies and that the U.S. was the “cleanest country in the planet.” None of that was true.

President Trump on Tuesday at the Charleston Civic Center in Charleston, W.Va.Credit...Gabriella Demczuk for The New York Times

what was said

“We love clean, beautiful West Virginia coal. We love it. And you know that’s indestructible stuff. In times of war, in times of conflict, you can blow up those windmills. They fall down real quick. You can blow up those pipelines. They go like this and you’re not going to fix them too fast. You can do a lot of things to those solar panels. But you know what you can’t hurt? Coal.”

— President Trump, at a campaign rally on Tuesday in Charleston, W.Va.

the facts

If coal itself were truly indestructible, you couldn’t mine or burn it. Anthracite coal is hard, but yields to a hammer; you can crumble soft lignite in your hand. (The term “clean coal” is also a misnomer.)

The notion that coal-fired plants are somehow trouble-free and secure is also mistaken. In June, Westar Energy shut down Kansas’ largest power plant after an equipment failure led to the deaths of two employees, and an industrial accident shut down a Florida plant in 2017. In World War II, British bombers targeted the coal plants and stockpiles that powered the steel mills of the Ruhr Valley in Germany.

Mr. Trump has also argued that coal is more reliable than solar and wind power systems, which do not generate when the sun does not shine and the wind dies. This argument ignores the efforts to develop innovative energy storage systems to smooth those curves of supply and demand.

what was said

“We are back. The coal industry is back.”

the facts

Mr. Trump lauded his administration’s attempts on many fronts to roll back environmental policies from President Barack Obama’s administration that encouraged the transition to renewable energy sources, including this week’s announcement of a proposed replacement for Mr. Obama’s signature Clean Power Plan.

But despite all of Mr. Trump’s efforts, the industry remains under heavy economic pressure from cheap natural gas and the rise of renewable energy. Coal consumption has continued to decline, and production too was lower in the first three months of 2018 compared with last year. The economy added about 2,200 jobs in the coal sector from February 2017, Mr. Trump’s first full month in office, to July 2018 — a modest increase of about 4.3 percent.

what was said

“When I came here originally, West Virginia, frankly, was down and out. It was not doing exactly well. One of the last. Do you know that a few months ago, it hit where West Virginia is, on a per capita basis, one of the most successful G.D.P. states in our union?”

the facts

According to the Bureau of Economic Analysis, West Virginia ranked 47th out of 50 states in 2017 at a per capita gross domestic product of $37,353, after adjusting for inflation.

Mr. Trump may have been thinking of the increase in the state’s gross domestic product, which he has lauded in the past, but he would also be wrong about that. West Virginia’s economy grew at a rate of 1.3 percent in the first quarter of 2018, placing it at No. 37.

what was said

“I want clean air. I want crystal clean water. And we’ve got it. We’ve got the cleanest country in the planet right now. There’s nobody cleaner than us.”

the facts

The United States ranked 27th out of 180 countries in an environmental performance review, compiled by Yale and Columbia University researchers in collaboration with the World Economic Forum in 2018. (Switzerland topped the list.)

The Environmental Performance Index assigns the ranking based on 10 categories, including air and water quality, biodiversity, and climate and energy. The United States ranked the highest in agriculture, at No. 2, and the lowest in forests, at No. 115.

Other claims

Mr. Trump made a number of other false or misleading claims that The New York Times has previously debunked:

Sources: The New York Times, The Wichita Eagle, “Air Battle of the Ruhr,” Energy Information Administration, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Bureau of Economic Analysis, Environmental Performance Index.

Linda Qiu is a fact-check reporter, based in Washington. She came to The Times in 2017 from the fact-checking service PolitiFact. More about Linda Qiu

John Schwartz is part of the climate team. Since joining The Times in 2000, he has covered science, law, technology, the space program and more, and has written for almost every section. More about John Schwartz

Advertisement

SKIP ADVERTISEMENT